Artificial intelligence can now produce illustrations, advertising copy, music, video, and software code in seconds. For the businesses using those tools, speed of creation does not translate into ownership. Practicing in Los Angeles, where studios, agencies, and independent creators are generating more AI-assisted work than almost anywhere else, I now field this question weekly, and the answer has become clearer at one end of the spectrum while the middle remains unsettled. 

United States law is now settled on the easy case: a work created entirely by artificial intelligence, with no human author, cannot be copyrighted. The harder question is what happens when a person develops the concept, directs an AI system through many iterations, selects among outputs, rewrites and edits, and produces something that would not exist without substantial human creative judgment. That is where founders and creative teams need to focus, because the important question is not whether AI appeared somewhere in the workflow. It is which expressive elements a human being actually authored. 

This article reflects the state of U.S. law as of October 2026 and is educational rather than legal advice. The area is still developing, and the analysis of any particular work depends on exactly how it was created. 

Copyright Still Requires a Human Author 

The controlling case is Thaler v. Perlmutter. Stephen Thaler sought to register an image he said was generated autonomously by his AI system, and he named the machine itself as the author. The Copyright Office refused, a district court agreed in 2023, and on March 18, 2025 the D.C. Circuit affirmed that the Copyright Act requires a human author. Thaler petitioned the Supreme Court, and on March 2, 2026 the Court denied review, leaving the D.C. Circuit’s decision in place. 

Two points about Thaler are routinely misread. First, the court did not hold that every work touched by AI is ineligible; the defect was that the claimed author was the machine. Second, the Supreme Court’s denial is not a ruling on the merits, so the human-authorship requirement stands on the strength of the appellate decision rather than a nationwide pronouncement. For businesses, the working rule is nonetheless clear: AI can be part of the creative process, but AI cannot be the author. 

Using AI Does Not Automatically Forfeit Protection 

A work does not lose copyright merely because AI helped create it. The Copyright Office’s January 2025 report, Copyright and Artificial Intelligence, Part 2: Copyrightability, concluded that existing law can accommodate AI-assisted creation without a statutory rewrite. Protection exists where a human determines sufficient expressive elements of the resulting work: where human-authored material remains perceptible in the final product, where a person creatively selects, coordinates, or arranges AI-generated material, or where a person meaningfully modifies AI output. The copyright then covers the human authorship, not every component the system generated. 

I find that distinction far more useful than asking whether something is an “AI work.” The label tells me almost nothing. One person asks a system for an image and publishes the first result unchanged. Another uses the same software as one step in a process involving original sketches, dozens of design decisions, compositing, and final artistic judgment. Both can truthfully say they used AI, and they are in materially different copyright positions. 

Prompting Alone Is a Weak Foundation 

The Office’s current position is that providing prompts, however detailed, generally does not give the user enough control over the expressive elements of the output to make the user its author. In the Part 2 report, the Office treated prompts as instructions conveying a desired result rather than as control over the specific expression produced. A person can describe subject, lighting, mood, palette, and composition in extraordinary detail and still receive output the person did not actually determine. 

This is the point where older online explanations are most likely to mislead. The Office has acknowledged the analysis is fact dependent and that a future system offering substantially greater control over expressive details could present a different case. But as the law stands today, I would not build a company’s copyright strategy on the assumption that elaborate prompting establishes ownership. It is also where copyright and patent law have quietly diverged. On the patent side, the USPTO’s November 2025 guidance treats AI as a tool and asks whether a human contributed enough to the conception of the invention, a framework I walked through in Who Owns an Invention Created with AI? A founder using AI across both product development and creative output should not assume the two agencies will reach the same answer about the same workflow. 

The Case That Will Define the Middle 

If Thaler settled the easy end, Allen v. Perlmutter may define the harder one. Jason Allen created Théâtre D’opéra Spatial with Midjourney, reportedly through hundreds of prompt iterations followed by additional image processing. Unlike Thaler, he does not claim the AI is the author; he argues his own creative participation was sufficient. The Copyright Office refused to register the AI-generated portion, finding he did not control the expressive elements Midjourney produced, and Allen sued in the District of Colorado. As of October 2026, the case remains pending with summary judgment fully briefed. 

I am watching this one closely because it asks the question most businesses actually have. No one I work with is trying to list a model as the author. They want to know how much human direction is enough when AI is used as a sophisticated tool, and Allen is the first court test of that boundary. 

Where Human Authorship Can Live 

Human modification of AI output qualifies for protection when the modification itself contains original expression. Picture a designer who takes an AI-generated illustration, redraws portions, changes characters, restructures the composition, and integrates it into a larger human-designed piece. The underlying AI expression stays unprotected, but the designer’s copyright extends to what the designer contributed. The same logic applies to text: an AI rough draft that a writer substantially restructures, rewrites, and develops with original examples can carry substantial human authorship in the finished work. 

Selection and arrangement is the second path, and it predates generative AI. An original selection or arrangement of material can be protected even when the individual elements are not. A person who chooses particular AI images, decides how they relate to human-written text, and sequences them into a composition may own copyright in that arrangement. The resulting right is narrower than people expect, though. It protects the human-created arrangement without granting exclusive rights over the individual AI-generated images inside it, and that distinction becomes very important the day the company tries to enforce the copyright against someone who copied one image. 

Document Authorship While the Work Is Being Made 

For companies using generative AI, documentation has become part of intellectual property strategy. Six months after a campaign, interface, video, or content library ships, reconstructing what came from a person and what came from a tool is hard, and the problem becomes serious during registration, licensing, financing, acquisition diligence, or enforcement. I want a client to be able to show where human expression entered the work: meaningful drafts, human source material, significant revisions, design files, and version history. The goal is not mountains of paperwork because AI was used. It is preserving evidence of authorship for the assets whose value may one day depend on it. 

Registration is where that record gets tested. The Office’s registration guidance directs applicants to identify the human authorship being claimed and to exclude AI-generated material that is more than de minimis, and it has told applicants who previously filed without doing so to correct the record. An application is not the place to take the most aggressive view of authorship and hope nobody asks how the work was made. 

Output and Training Are Separate Questions 

Two AI copyright debates are constantly blended together and should be kept apart. The first asks whether an AI-assisted output contains enough human authorship to be protected; that is the subject of the Part 2 report and this article. The second asks whether an AI developer infringes copyright by training on protected works; that is the subject of the Office’s Part 3 report, released in pre-publication form on May 9, 2025 and, as of this writing, still awaiting a final version. A company should not assume that because its own output is protectable, every use of copyrighted material elsewhere in the AI pipeline is permissible. One question concerns authorship; the other concerns use of someone else’s work. 

For founders, the practical issue is asset management. Companies are producing logos, advertisements, product imagery, interfaces, and written content with AI somewhere in the workflow, and if those assets matter to the brand or the revenue, uncertainty about ownership becomes an investor, licensing, or enforcement problem. I would not make the internal rule “do not use AI.” I would make it “know how AI was used and preserve the human contribution.” If an important asset was essentially produced autonomously, the company should understand that copyright may not deliver the exclusivity it assumes it has. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

Can I copyright an image I created with AI? 

Possibly, depending on the human authorship in the work. A purely AI-generated image generally will not qualify, while original human modifications, human source material, or a creative selection and arrangement may be protectable. 

Does writing detailed AI prompts give me copyright ownership? 

Under the Copyright Office’s current position, prompts alone generally do not give enough control over the expressive elements of the output to establish authorship. That could change as tools change, but detailed prompting should not be treated as an automatic path to ownership today. 

Can I copyright something ChatGPT helped me write? 

Using an AI tool does not by itself prevent protection. The question is whether the final work contains sufficient original human expression. If you meaningfully write, rewrite, restructure, and develop the text, those human-created portions may qualify. 

Do I have to disclose AI use when registering a copyright? 

Yes, where it is more than de minimis. The Copyright Office requires applicants to identify the human authorship claimed and to disclaim significant AI-generated material. How that applies depends on the work and the role AI played. 

Did the Supreme Court decide that AI-assisted works cannot be copyrighted? 

No. The Court declined to review Thaler v. Perlmutter on March 2, 2026, which leaves the D.C. Circuit’s human-authorship requirement in place. That decision bars AI itself from being an author; it does not hold that using AI as a tool makes a work ineligible. 

The Human Contribution Is Now the Central Question 

By 2026, one part of this area is settled: AI cannot be the author of a copyrighted work, and the Supreme Court’s refusal to hear Thaler leaves that requirement firmly in place. The more important question for most companies is how much expression came from a person and how clearly that contribution can be shown. For businesses building valuable creative assets with AI, documenting human authorship and understanding what the company can actually protect belongs inside the creative process, not after it. 

I am Omid Khalifeh, an intellectual property attorney in Los Angeles and the founder of Omni Legal Group. My practice covers copyright, trademark, patent, and internet law for founders, creators, and technology companies. You can read more about my background and experience here. 

If your company is developing AI-assisted content, artwork, software, or media, I would be glad to talk through how copyright protection applies to the way you actually work. Through Omni Legal Group, my team handles copyright registration and enforcement for creative businesses, and you can schedule a confidential consultation before an important asset is built on assumptions the law does not support. 

One Comment

Leave a Reply